Tyrbo Make your game

Why AI sprite animations wobble, and what we measured to stop it

Tyrbo · · 5 min read

Ask an image model for a walk cycle and you will usually get four nice drawings that do not quite agree with each other. Played in a loop, the character shimmers: the stripes on its shirt crawl, its face shifts, its sword grows and shrinks. Animators call it boil. A little is charming in a hand-drawn film. In a game you stare at for an hour, it reads as broken.

In early November 2026 we ran four different ways of animating 2D characters side by side and measured the boil instead of eyeballing it. Here is what we found.

How we measured it

We made six new characters across four style families and animated each of them four ways:

  1. A drawn sheet. One image call asked for the whole walk, the way most tools do it today.
  2. A puppet. One picture of the character, cut onto 2D bones and bent into every frame, with squash and stretch on top.
  3. Pixel art. A small walk sheet, cleaned up to true pixels, one palette and one baseline.
  4. Stacked pieces. Heads and bodies drawn as separate parts and assembled.

Then we needed a number. The one we used is the share of the character's body whose texture changes in a way a plain slide or turn cannot explain. If you move a sticker across a table, nothing about it boils, so we checked the measure on exactly that kind of rigid move first. Rigid moves scored between 0 and 1.7%. Anything well above that is the drawing itself changing.

The drawn sheet boiled badly

The one-call drawn sheet gave four drawings per walk loop and boiled between 37% and 57%. That is not a subtle shimmer. Somewhere between a third and more than half of the character was being redrawn every frame.

The puppet, by contrast, produced 17 to 27 frames per loop and boiled between 0.1% and 3.2%. Same characters, same looks. The difference is that a puppet never redraws the character. It only moves the one picture it has.

The surprise: squash and stretch was the leftover wobble

Even the puppet boiled a little, and we expected the cause to be fiddly technical stuff. So we tried sharper weights on the bones, and drawing every frame on whole pixels. Neither changed anything.

The real cause was squash and stretch on the whole body. It is a classic animation trick, and it does make a jump feel springy, but stretching the entire character every frame of a walk smears its texture. Turning it off in looping moves brought the puppet down to 0.1 to 1.6%, right in the range of a rigid move. Now a squash is a light one on the whole figure about its feet, kept for the moments that earn it.

Proportions matter as much as motion

A related study looked at why some 2D rigs came out lopsided. When we asked the image model to draw a character's parts separately (a head, an arm, a leg), the parts were 11% to 36% off in size on average, and one part was nearly twice the size it should have been. Drawing slots that showed the right sizes did not help: the model ignored them.

What worked was drawing the whole character once, in a pose that suits a rig, and cutting that one picture into parts. The sizes are then right by construction, because they all come from the same drawing.

Faces get their own layer

A face is where you notice wobble first. So a character with a visible face gets a small set of expressions, drawn as edits of its own head and fitted back onto it: determined in an attack, wincing in a hit, dizzy in a defeat. Each one rides on the head as a patch and is switched per move. If an expression does not fit, it is left out and reported, never pasted on as a second face.

The routes in Tyrbo, and when to pick each

Everything above ended up as choices on the 2D animation row of each game's Settings tab:

  • Auto is the default. The builder picks per character: a pixel look gets drawn frames, a blob, serpent or flier gets the puppet, and anything else is filmed from its picture.
  • Puppet bends every character from its one picture. It is free and holds still, and it is strongest for soft, simple bodies.
  • Sprite sheet draws four poses per clip. It boils more, and in a pixel or retro look that frame-by-frame feel is the point.
  • Video films each character from its picture and cuts the clips to a sheet. It keeps a painted design on model; we wrote up how that route works separately.
  • 3D made 2D sculpts the character on a skeleton and renders its moves from your game's camera, cel-lit and outlined, the way some isometric action games get their crisp sprites. One test, a caped warrior, came out as 96 frames of idle, walk and a sword attack, front and back, in 16 seconds.
  • Simple makes no animation calls at all. A still picture is moved by the game's own pops, shivers, squashes and stretches, which suits a lot of puzzle and card games.

A puppet clip that still boils past 3% is flagged in the build's report, so you know where to look.

What to do with this as a maker

If your game is pixel art, leave the drawn frames alone; a little boil is part of the style. If it is painted or hand-drawn and the hero is on screen the whole time, care about boil, because players feel it before they can name it. When something shimmers, tell Tyrbo which character and which move ("the knight's walk flickers around the tabard") and it can redo that one clip by another route without touching the rest.

Questions people ask

Why does my AI-generated sprite flicker when it walks?

Because each frame was drawn separately, so details like stripes, eyes and edges move between drawings. In our tests a walk drawn in one call boiled across 37% to 57% of the body. Moving one picture instead of redrawing it brought that down to a few percent.

Is squash and stretch bad for game animation?

No, but it costs something. Stretching the whole body every frame of a looping walk smeared the texture in our tests. Keeping it for jumps, landings and hits, and off in walk and idle loops, kept the character steady.

Which animation style should I choose for a 2D game?

Match it to the look. Pixel art suits drawn frames. Painted characters keep their design best when filmed or rendered. Blobs, serpents and fliers move well as free puppets. On a quiet puzzle or card game, still pictures with code-driven squash and shivers are often all you need.

Can I change the animation route after the game is built?

You can ask for a character or a single move to be redone by another route at any time. The Settings tab setting decides how new characters are animated from the next turn on.

Make the game this guide is about.

Make your game

Sign in to get the plan and its concept art. Both are free.